1.

"Go from seriousness to absurd from one blog post to the next in this strange, yet not harmful, blog." - - Health Expert Blog on Musings


Biting the Cyanide Capsule

by Rob on October 14, 2008 · Comments

in American Medicine, Rants

Vote This Post DownVote This Post Up (+9 rating, 2 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...

From WSJ:

Weak Economy Could Mean Medicaid Pay Cuts for Doctors

Not long after an epic battle over Medicare pay, doctors are bracing themselves for cuts from state Medicaid programs.

Blame the weak economy. States, which fund much of Medicaid, have fewer tax revenues coming into their coffers. Meanwhile, as more people lose jobs with health benefits, they are more likely to sign up for Medicaid, which serves the poor.

The result: “Doctors’ fees could be on the chopping block if states can’t cover their costs,” reports American Medical News, published by the American Medical Association.

AMNews cites a report on state Medicaid programs from the Kaiser Commission on Medicaid and the Uninsured that found enrollment grew by 2.1% in fiscal 2008 after a 0.5% decline in 2007, while at the same time spending increased 5.3%, the fastest incline since 2005. States expect bigger increases in both enrollment and spending in 2009, according to Kaiser.

Cutting doctor pay is tempting because it creates savings faster than cutting benefits does, Vernon Smith, a co-author of the Kaiser report and a principal at the research and consulting firm Health Management Associates, told American Medical News.

Dumb.  Really dumb.

I accept Medicaid in my practice, but have started to consider if it is really worth the small amount paid.  We are one of the already dwindling number of offices accepting it.

So what effect would cutting Medicaid reimbursement have?  Doctors like myself would withdraw from the program.  My income does not depend on Medicaid, so I would see very little effect on my bottom line (in fact, it could increase as low-paying Medicaid patients are replaced with better-paying privately insured patients).  Less doctors accepting Medicaid would worsen an already serious shortage of physicians available for these patients.

cyanide What is the result of decreased access to PCP’s?  ER visits.  A rise in the number of ER visits would be inevitable (especially as the patients are not themselves financially penalized for using the more expensive ER over a PCP).  This would significantly raise the cost to the system and worsen the financial shortfall for the Medicaid program.  Cutting reimbursement would be the equivalent of biting the cyanide capsule – it would result in sure collapse of the system.

Ironically, the best thing they could do would be to raise physician reimbursement for PCP’s.  This would increase the number of PCP’s on the Medicaid roster and decrease ER visits.

This is not a “maybe” scenario – I am one of those physicians that would be pushed toward dropping Medicaid if my reimbursement went down.  As much as I like some of my Medicaid patients (and I do like a lot of them), I can’t afford to work at a loss.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!Share This Post

Related posts:

  1. American Medicine: The Income Gap I have to make a confession. I am bitter. I...
  2. American Medicine – The Death of Primary Care   Primary care is dying.  If and when it does,...
  3. News Flash: Free care makes no money In a shocking development, researchers found that Patient-Doctor E-mail Could...
  4. 10 Dumb things about Medicaid I read many rants on Medicare (and write some myself),...
  5. Open for Business I worked the late shift today. I started out...

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

  • m (2)
    "Medicaid pay cut" seems redundant, somehow.
  • Your case makes perfect sense. I really encourage you to write to your Congressman/Senator about it. When I worked in DC this summer, all the health insurance hearings I went to had economists or administrators as witnesses, and several of the Members of Congress stated that they wanted to hear from "the stakeholders" -- physicians and patients. It was the outcry from people like yourself and your patients that reversed the Medicare cuts this summer. The same can be done for Medicaid, if enough people care to write.
  • Ken O.
    Dr Rob's business case makes sense to me, and there's historical prescedent for the scenario he outlines, from when our Government cut NHS reembursement rates to dentists, and the majority of them responded by stopping NHS treatment.
  • Robert
    It's truly distressing to see that Medicaid is the first place where they plan to cut the budget. For your information, the defense industry is about to receive $487.7 billion worth of contracts, according to WSJ (here). ARGHH!
  • About a year ago, our practice went through the difficult discussion of whether to no longer accept medicaid. We went through all the pros and cons of this issue. Even though it meant letting go of a lot of great patients and families, our group decided to withdraw from treating medicaid patients a few months ago.

    I see those patients every day whether at the store or at soccer games. Of course some are angry about it, but the majority of them understand our decision. Also during that transition time, I tried to educate my patients on the state medicaid system. There are few medicaid accepting docs in this county - so access to care has become a major issue around here on the local level.

    Some of my patients are even getting involved in this election cycle, particularly in county and state office races - solely because of this medicaid issue. Finally, I do have hope that when our state medicaid system collapses, the rebuilt version will allow our practice (because of less hastles and possibly more payment) to see our patients again.
  • a family doc
    Maybe they're not so dumb. Private practices are also a dwindling part the provider mix in many locations. The growing percentage of hospital based clinics are usually unable to drop Medicaid, either due to their mission or regulations.

    Many private practices will likely be dropping Medicaid anyway as the no copay Medicaid patients will not slow their demand for appointments while the paying patients either come in less often or switch to Medicaid if they lose their jobs. The rate Medicaid pays is only one factor determining the financial impact it has on a practice.

    While some of the Medicaid patients will go to the ER, many will simply defer care if they can't find a physician or if their physician's schedule is overwhelmed by too many patients. Access problems are a crude but effective way to save money or ration care.

    I'm not implying that this is a good thing, merely that the state Medicaid administrators may have already thought this through. They're in a tough spot.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post:

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes